Didn't sell? Questions owners ask

Was it the broker or the process?

Offsell.com editorial team · Last reviewed

How do I choose the best business broker for my business?

The short answer

The best broker is not necessarily the largest firm, the cheapest adviser or the one quoting the highest valuation. Look at how they identify buyers, whether they understand the strategic deal drivers, how many relevant acquirers they will research, who conducts the outreach, their transaction experience, how they challenge value expectations and how their fees are structured.

The Offsell view

The most revealing question is: why would those buyers want my business? An adviser who can answer it buyer by buyer is thinking about acquisition rationale, not just sector lists.

Questions to ask before you instruct anyone

Question to askWhy it matters
How will you identify potential buyers?Tests whether the process extends beyond listings
Why would those buyers want my business?Tests whether the adviser understands deal drivers
How do you distinguish financial and strategic buyers?Tests buyer-strategy sophistication
How many credible buyers will you research?Tests market coverage
Who will approach them?Clarifies execution
How will outreach differ by buyer?Tests whether the process is genuinely targeted
How is valuation established?Helps avoid an unrealistic launch
What happens if buyer response is poor?Tests adaptability
Who handles offers and negotiation?Tests transaction capability
What do I pay upfront?Tests commercial alignment
What happens if the mandate ends?Identifies tail and protected-buyer issues

Should you pay a business broker upfront? Compare fee types and payment triggers.

A high valuation is not necessarily a sign of a good broker.

An adviser may recommend an ambitious value for legitimate reasons, a strong strategic fit, a competitive market, or genuine upside. What matters is the evidence behind it and how market feedback will be used if buyers disagree.

Ask what the value is based on, what would cause it to be revisited, and when.

Choosing a second adviser after an unsuccessful sale

The first question is what will be different. A second adviser should be able to explain, in specifics, how their process differs from the one that did not complete.

  1. What do you think was different about the first process, and what would you change?
  2. How do you research buyers, and how many would you expect to approach directly?
  3. How do you decide which buyers to approach, and which to exclude?
  4. How is confidentiality handled before and after an NDA?
  5. What happens when buyers decline? How is feedback recorded and used?
  6. What are the fees, retainers and any Heads of Terms payment, and when is each payable?
  7. How do you treat buyers protected under my previous agreement, and what tail period would your own agreement include?
  8. How and how often will you report activity and results?

Business didn't sell: next steps

What should you do next?

  1. 01Speak to more than one adviser and ask each the same questions.
  2. 02Ask for an example of how they positioned a business to a specific type of buyer.
  3. 03Read the fee terms in full, including Total Deal Value, tail periods and minimums.

Find out why before you simply try again.

We don't list businesses. We find buyers. £0 upfront is our standard service for qualifying UK businesses.

Take the Fresh Sale Review

Off-market · Confidential · What to do when a business doesn't sell