Did your broker actually find the market?
| Look at | What good looks like |
|---|---|
| Buyer research | A researched list of named acquirers, not a sector category |
| Direct outreach | Buyers approached individually, not only via a listing |
| Buyer relevance | Each buyer has a plausible reason to want this business |
| Strategic rationale | The approach explains what the acquisition could add for that buyer |
| Follow-up | More than one contact, over a sensible period |
| Feedback | Recorded reasons for declining, shared with you |
| Momentum | The strategy changes when response is poor |
Listing a business is not the same as finding the buyer.
Listing-led
Advertise → wait → respond
Depends on the right buyer seeing an advert and choosing to enquire.
We don't list businesses. We find buyers.
Was it the process, or something else?
Signs the previous sale process may have underperformed
- Very limited buyer research
- Heavy reliance on public advertising
- No evidence of direct strategic outreach
- Buyers chosen only because they were in the same sector
- No clear deal rationale
- Weak follow-up
- Poor activity reporting
- Little useful buyer feedback
- Long periods of inactivity
- Unrealistic valuation left unchallenged
- No meaningful strategy change when activity was poor
Signs the issue may have been elsewhere
- Consistent buyer feedback that value was too high
- Deteriorating trading
- Owner dependence
- Customer concentration
- Diligence problems
- Unwillingness to accept market terms
- Buyer finance failure
- Adverse sector conditions
A process can show some of both. The balance between them tells you what needs to change.
What evidence should you ask your adviser for?
Before deciding what went wrong, gather the record of what actually happened. A well-run process should be able to show most of this:
- The list of buyers approached, and how each was identified
- Contact status for each: approached, followed up, responded, declined
- Who signed an NDA and who received information
- Meetings held and the questions buyers raised
- Stated reasons for decline, where given
- Any indications of value, formal or informal
- Channels used: direct outreach, listings, databases or networks
What should you do before replacing your adviser?
Check your agreement first: whether it has ended, any notice period, and whether buyers introduced during the mandate remain protected. Then decide whether the issue was the adviser, the value, the business, or timing. A new adviser running the same process at the same value is unlikely to produce a different result.
When does a fresh buyer search make sense?
A fresh search is most likely to help where the previous buyer list was short or generic, relied mainly on listings, or excluded whole categories of acquirer, and where the value expectation is supported by evidence. It is less likely to help if buyers engaged properly and gave consistent feedback about the business itself.
Off-market does not mean passive.
A fresh search should be researched, direct and built on what the first process learned.
What should you do next?
- 01Request the list of buyers approached, how they were contacted and their responses.
- 02Check your agreement for notice, exclusivity, tail periods and protected buyers.
- 03Note any buyer feedback on value, it is the most useful evidence you have.
- 04Get a fresh view before appointing anyone else.
Find out why before you simply try again.
We don't list businesses. We find buyers. £0 upfront is our standard service for qualifying UK businesses.
Get a fresh viewOff-market · Confidential · What to do when a business doesn't sell
